You can copy and paste this URL.
This URL will permanently link back to this page.
Verbal Complaints are protected under the Provisions of the FLSA
In a Supreme Court decision earlier this year, the High Court ruled in the Kasten versus Saint-Gobain Performance Plastics Corporation case that an employee's verbal complaints concerning alleged wage and hour violations can be adequate to trigger the anti-retaliation tenets of the Fair Labor Standards Act, or FLSA (Santucci & Dick, 2011). The plaintiff, one Kevin Kasten, formerly employed by Saint-Gobain, had alleged that he had been terminated from his position with the company in retaliation for his having complained to his supervisors and human-resources department staffers about the position of the time clocks in the company.
Mr. Kasten had complained about the Placement of the Clocks in the Company
Mr. Kasten had complained that the clocks were inconveniently located which made it impossible for employees to record the time they spent “donning and doffing” protective equipment (Santucci & Dick, 2011). The High Court, in short, had to decide whether or not the phrase “filed any complaint” in the statutory language of the FLSA included verbal and written complaints.
The District and Seventh Circuit Courts had ruled against Mr. Kasten, the Plaintiff
The District Court ruled in the defendant's favor and determined that the FLSA anti-retaliation provisions did not cover verbal complaints which was upheld by the Seventh Circuit Court. The Supreme Court over-ruled both of the lower courts' rulings, however, and maintained that verbal complaints are indeed covered under the anti-retaliation tenets of the FLSA (Santucci & Dick, 2011).
The Supreme Court’s Over-ruling of the Lower Courts Hinged on Several Factors
The Supreme Court's rationale for over-ruling the lower courts and in the plaintiff's favor hinged upon several considerations (Santucci & Dick, 2011):
1. Limiting the provisions of the anti-retaliation rules to written complaints only would weaken the FLSA's basic intentions.
2. The purpose of the Act is to assure a safe and healthy work environment and to assure that workers’ wages and hours are properly recorded and that they are paid accurately as they should. Enforcement of the Act, ruled the High Court, should not have to rest on federal monitoring on an ongoing basis but rather on the nature of the complaints received from the employees seeking to vindicate that their rights have been violated by their employers.
3. The anti-retaliation provision, both written and oral, undergirds the enforcement construct by preventing fear of economic retaliation from forcing employees to quietly submit to substandard conditions.
4. The Supreme Court set forth a test for determining the legitimacy of an FLSA-based complaint which is if a reasonable or objective person would have “fair notice” that an employee was asserting statutory rights then that worker would be protected under the provisions of the FLSA.
5. This High Court decision has expanded the reach of employer liability relative to the FLSA and its enforcement.
6. Given this expanded scope of employer liability, organizations of all types should ensure that they are compliant in all areas of hours, wages, overtime, and working-condition regulations and policies.
7. Employers should mitigate the risk of litigation by conducting FLSA training and workshops in their entities on a regular basis, with updates clearly communicated throughout the entity.
8. Moreover, when employees are first hired, they should be well-grounded in all aspects of FLSA policies and practices and deeply steeped in other aspects of human-resources policies and practices to enhance their value to themselves, their organizations, and their communities.
Source: Santucci, Adam & Dick, Tony D., Esq., (2011). Supreme Court Says Verbal Complaints of Alleged FSLA Violations are Protected. Pennsylvania Labor & Employment Blog, May 18, 2011. McNees, Wallace, & Nurick LLC; Harrisburg, PA and other offices around Pennsylvania, Ohio, and Washington, DC. Retrieved from: http://www.jdsupra.com/post/documentViewer.aspx?fid=d179512c-1f12-4c39-bf01-00774cb5200b
This new Article is not yet ready for syndication. Please check back in a few minutes.
This Article is not available for syndication. Contact BestThinking for details.
Enjoy high quality content through BestThinking's syndication program. Learn more and register as a publisher today!
Enhance your publication, blog or journal with high quality content from BestThinking. Whether you are looking for a single feature article, a stream of dynamic content or just a few pieces each month, BestThinking's unique, customizable syndication feeds provide rights-verified material from identity verified Thinkers.
To syndicate a Blog or Article, you’ll need to start by setting up a feed. Creating a feed is a 3-step process:
Major Media Content Experiment Ends
We will no longer be adding major media content, such as news from the Associated Press, alongside our Thinker content. This will result in the elimination of the "News" content type.
Going forward, we will focus exclusively on Thinker Blogs, Articles, Topics, and Ebooks. Visit our CEO's blog for the thinking behind this change. We want to thank the people of the Associated Press who were very supportive of our ideas and a pleasure to work with.
About the Author
Dave S Morse
I've completed a Masters of Management in Public Administration at the University of Phoenix and am seeking to enter the field of social and
Theory E vis-à-vis Theory O Theory E espouses organizational change based on economic value whereas Theory O commends entity change founded upon organizational value (Harvard Business Review, 2000). Though the tide is beginning to change, most companies in the U.S., particularly large ones,...
A Blinkered Focus on Profitability Senior corporate leadership, boards of directors, and shareholders often have a monocular focus on the short-term bottom line and in the interest of “profitability” make extremely poor decisions relative to downsizing. Oftentimes, companies engage in...
Compensation Decisions Must also Have a Community Interface Many times organizational leaders base employee-compensation decisions on performance-related criteria only. While this is extremely important for compensation fairness to every employee, compensation decisions must also be measured...
HRIS technology drives organizational success in that it enables the speeding up of human-resource administrative procedures which enable more accurate and rapid tracking of the best matched, and most well-qualified, candidates for a particular position and frees HR staff from the mundane.
This article examines gaps of perception that often exist between Boards of Trustees/Chancellors in Community College Districts and the constituents they serve. Such gaps are most acute between Boards/Chancellors and colleges which serve poor communities, especially in how budget cuts are applied.
This article highlights four staffing models which are essential for the recruitment and retention of the best qualified and most well-matched personnel to meet the staffing needs of organizations and to keep them competitive and growing over the long-term.